Justice requires a disproportionate response
If you could cut through all the Kofi-speak to the heart of the matter, what do you think would be a “proportionate” response to the provocations Israel has endured? Do the Israelis have to fire Qassam rockets into Gaza at Hamas? Do Jewish kids have to strap on bomb belts and blow themselves up in Ramallah?The contemptible blather about "disproportionate response" comes from people who refuse to distinguish between the aggressor and the victim -- who remain morally neutral as to which one ought to prevail, and thus believe that "fairness" requires each to have an equal chance.
...
As someone recently said, it’s like a bank robbery — when the call comes in that three men are robbing a bank, then the cops can only send in three patrolmen to stop them.
Or imagine that you’re woken up in the middle of the night by a burglar in the living room. You grab your twelve-gauge and creep down the stairs very quietly. But when you flip on the light and surprise the burglar, he’s armed with only a knife! What do you do? Why, you drop the shotgun, rush to the kitchen, and rummage through the drawers for a knife. And not just any knife — it has to be no longer or sharper than the one the burglar has!
For those of us who insist that there is no right to rape, mug, burgle -- or murder (again!) six million Jews -- the concept of proportionality of response is a moral abomination. The correct response to aggression is whatever is necessary to stop it, to punish the aggressor, and to prevent repetition of the aggression in the future. The correct response to Islamofascism is to wipe it out. Decent people, of course, do their best to minimize harm to innocent bystanders -- and the extremely low number of deaths, given the number of air strikes and artillery bombardments, makes it clear that Israel is taking extraordinary measures in this regard. Perhaps too much so.
It's not only unwise, it's downright wrong to stay your hand so much that the aggressor might win -- or survive to prey on more victims in the future. Don't those future victims have just as much claim on your concern as the bystanders today? More so, in my opinion, if the bystanders aren't so innocent -- and that's certainly the case for most of the "civilian casualties" counted up by the media in southern Lebanon. These are the people who support Hezbollah, store Hezbollah weapons in their houses, and cheer on and resupply the Hezbollah fighters -- likely, their brothers and sons -- firing rockets from their doorsteps.
I'm joining the good Baron, and saying to our friends in Israel, "Bring on the Disproportionate Response!"
UPDATE: Welcome, visitors from The Atheist Jew -- please have a look around. You may see some post titles in the left sidebar that interest you.
UPDATE 2: The latest version of the proportionality complaint, blathered about endlessly on MSM outlets on Thursday, is the disparity between the number of Israeli deaths and Lebanese deaths (which are almost all Hezbollah deaths). The morally neutral "fairness" advocates object to the fact that Israel wages war more effectively than Hezbollah!
Would these asshats like to see an international Handicapper General, a la Harrison Bergeron, reduce the effectiveness of Israel's weapons, tactics, and troops so that they don't have an unfair advantage over the genocidal maniacs on the other side?
If you're not familiar with Kurt Vonnegut's short story masterpiece, Harrison Bergeron, click that link and read it right now.
This reminds me of the school system we have where everyone must finish in
a tie so nobody gets their feeling hurt.
I have a question.
Excellent post. Agreed. When facing a bully one must SQUASH the bully so
there will be no question as to future attacks, and other bullies will take
heed. It is the ONLY option.
.
absurd thought -
God of the Universe says
never use nukes...
.
Ahmadinejad got his start in the hostage-taking business in 1979. The U.S.
Embassy in Tehran is now the HQ of Terror Cental (Al-Quds).
Let's nab these thugs and send 'em to GITMO to rot (and if a few of them get STOMPED by U.S. Marines, Army, Navy and Air Force, oh well.)
Thanks for the comment, John! I think the Brits need to ask themselves the
question WWMTD -- What Would Margaret Thatcher Do?
The recent kidnapping of 15 UK soldiers by Iran was done primarily to gain
the release of one of Iran's top Al-Quds agents captured in Iraq. The
business of Al-Quds is subversion, infiltration, murder, suppression of
dissent, propaganda and psychological warfare. Now, It is almost time for
Election 2008. What is Al-Quds' main target right now? The mind of your
child who loves to make friends on the Internet! Ask me (I beg you, I DARE
you) to back up that statement.
pelosi and the other democrat socialist traitors should be arrested, tried
for traeson, exicuted, by hanging from the golden gate bridge. and while I
am at it nuke syria, and Iran. and cuold some body tell the Isreal
government to stop playing with their enemy.
I am amazed at the depths of deceit zionists sink to while attmepting to
justify their OPPRESSION of Palestinians. It only takes common sense to
realize who the aggressor is...articles such as this one cannot be taken
seriously by any unbiased intelligent individual.
Why waste your time with proportionality vs disproportionate response? Why
hold back? If you don't want to try for nonviolent peace, just be honest
about it & use the maximum firepower. Nuke your enemies, destroy everyone
at once, including yourselves and the rest of the world and get it over
with! Otherwise it's just some stupid tit-for-tat game.